Skip to Main Content
It looks like you're using Internet Explorer 11 or older. This website works best with modern browsers such as the latest versions of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge. If you continue with this browser, you may see unexpected results.

Information Literacy Resources: Evaluate

Digital Learning Objects

 Icons Used in This Guide 

video game    text/tables  flash 

video Peer Review Articles in 5 Minutes

 
CONTENT: explains the peer review process
 
MEDIUM/TIME: video (5:00)
 
ASSESSMENT: no
 
NOTES: North Carolina State University, excellent coverage, though peer review is only one of several important concepts for students to understand as they evaluate their sources. 
 
WHY WE LIKE IT:: this is an outstanding tutorial

 

video Evaluating Information Using the CRAAP Test

CONTENT: CRAAP stands for Currency, Relevance, Accuracy, Authority and Purpose.

MEDIUM/TIME: video (5:28)
 
ASSESSMENT: no
 
NOTES: Johnson & Wales University. Thorough look at how to evaluate information (including why); includes 1 minute review at the end
 
WHY WE LIKE IT: very good explanation of CRAAP acronym
 
CONTENT: another take on how to evaluate websites using Authority, Timeliness and Objectivity
MEDIUM/TIME: video (4:00)
ASSESSMENT: no
NOTES: San Jose State U. Engaging video
WHY WE LIKE IT: PRIMO (2012)
CONTENT: checklist of criteria for thoroughly evaluating a web page
MEDIUM/TIME: text with links
ASSESSMENT: no
NOTES: UC Berkeley. Dense with information
WHY WE LIKE IT: by nationally recognized librarian, an authority on teaching web site evaluation

Critical Thinking

Additional Class Exercises to Promote Critical Thinking Skills

  • Compare the findings of a search on the open Internet and that of a library database. Discuss the quality and quantity of results from each source.  Use the Quick Sheet.
  • Compare 3 websites in conjunction with topics related to the class and cover the main evaluation criteria: authority, accuracy, objectivity, currency, purpose. For more on Evaluating Sources click here Use the Quick Sheet
  • Check on the accuracy of an article in Wikipedia on a chosen topic. Does the information match with two other reliable sources? Can we locate the citations from the references list? Find an article in a print or an online encyclopedia and compare it with the article from Wikipedia! 
  • Compare book reviews. Locate and read 3 reviews of a work. Use Kirkus, and JSTOR or Gale Student Resources in Context  (databases)
  • Analyze the content, style, and audience of 3 different journals in a given discipline.